Custom Cakes

from Family Fare Supermarkets!

Craft stunning, delectable custom cakes for all your celebrations.

Your Celebration Destination!

Birthdays, anniversaries, retirements, weddings, baby showers, or any special occasion – we’ll decorate a cake for your day or event. You have plenty of decoration options like personalized messaging, buttercream flowers and embellishments, free-standing characters from popular kids’ movies, or we can transform a cake with a cherished photo. Ask any of our bakery associates for details and place your order today!

Our bakery team is skilled and ready to assist you in creating a dessert to remember. Share your cake on Facebook and tag your store!

Custom Cake Process
1. Personalize

Choose your size, flavor, filling and frosting.

2. Create
Let our expert Bakers & Cake Decorators work their magic.
3. Pick Up
Choose a date and time and we’ll have it ready for your party!
Available Cake Sizes
Sheet Cake
  • 1/8 Sheet (serves 9-12)
  • 1/4 Sheet (serves 18-24)
  • 1/2 Sheet (serves 36-48)
  • Full Sheet (serves 72-96)
8" Round
  • 8" Round Single (serves 6-8)
  • 8" Round Double (serves 8-10)
5" Round
  • 5" Round Single (select locations)
  • 5" Round Double (select locations)
Flavors, Fillings & Icings
Cake Flavors
  • Chocolate
  • Marble
  • White
  • Yellow
  • Carrot (select locations)
Filling Options
  • Strawberry
  • Lemon
  • Raspberry
  • Bavarian (custard)
  • White Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • White Whipped Icing
  • Cherry (select locations)
  • Holland Cream (select locations)
  • Bavarian Chocolate (select locations)
Icing Flavors
  • White Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • White Whipped Icing
  • Chocolate Whipped Icing
  • Cream (select locations)

Custom Cakes from your favorite store

Ordering your next delicious custom-made cake is just a phone call away. Find your store below and give them a call to start your cake order today! 

Family Fare – Zeeland | Zeeland, MI | (616) 748-1427
Family Fare – Metro | Wyoming , MI | (616) 249-2817
Family Fare – Byron Center | Byron Center, MI | (616) 878-1767
Family Fare – Butternut | Holland , MI | (616) 399-4440
Family Fare – S. Washington | Holland , MI | (616) 392-7941
Family Fare – Allendale | Allendale, MI | (616) 895-6665
Family Fare – Georgetown | Hudsonville , MI | (616) 669-5790
Family Fare – Leonard St. | Grand Rapids , MI | (616) 454-8368
Family Fare – Kentwood | Kentwood, MI | (616) 698-2604
Family Fare – Lake MI Dr. | Grand Rapids , MI | (616) 453-8251
Family Fare – Sparta | Sparta, MI | (616) 887-0737
Family Fare – Coopersville | Coopersville, MI | (616) 837-8919
Family Fare – Northland Dr. | Grand Rapids , MI | (616) 363-1000
Family Fare – Chum’s | Traverse City , MI | (231) 943-4080
Family Fare – 8th St. | Traverse City , MI | (231) 947-8239
Family Fare – Frankfort | Frankfort, MI | (231) 352-7151
Family Fare – Bellaire | Bellaire, MI | (231) 533-8724
Family Fare – Manistee | Manistee, MI | (231) 723-3434
Family Fare – Cadillac | Cadillac, MI | (231) 775-4233
Family Fare – Cheboygan | Cheboygan, MI | (231) 627-7161
Family Fare – Charlevoix | Charlevoix, MI | (231) 547-4223
Family Fare – Mio | Mio, MI | (989) 826-3614
Family Fare – Gaylord | Gaylord, MI | (989) 731-3222
Family Fare – Grayling | Grayling, MI | (989) 348-5011
Family Fare – Kalkaska | Kalkaska, MI | (231) 258-9966
Family Fare – Roscommon | Roscommon, MI | (989) 275-8426
Family Fare – Boyne City | Boyne City, MI | (231) 582-6614
Family Fare – Oscoda | Oscoda, MI | (989) 739-0262
Family Fare – Standish | Standish, MI | (989) 846-9574
Family Fare – Harrison | Harrison, MI | (989) 539-2108
Family Fare – Gladwin | Gladwin, MI | (989) 426-9215
Family Fare – Midland | Midland, MI | (989) 835-4851
Family Fare – Rockford | Rockford, MI | (616) 863-9372
Family Fare – Grandville | Grandville, MI | (616) 530-4566
Family Fare – Burlingame | Wyoming , MI | (616) 538-1840
Family Fare – Fulton Hts. | Grand Rapids , MI | (616) 459-3438
Family Fare – Jenison | Jenison, MI | (616) 457-9110
Family Fare – Ludington | Ludington, MI | (231) 845-6244
Family Fare – Lakeview | Battle Creek , MI | (269) 963-3300
Family Fare – Urbandale | Urbandale, MI | (269) 962-3302
Family Fare – Dowagiac | Dowagiac, MI | (269) 782-3258
Family Fare – Pennfield | Battle Creek , MI | (269) 964-3761
Family Fare – Paw Paw | Paw Paw, MI | (269) 657-7258
Family Fare – Hastings | Hastings, MI | (269) 945-2474
Family Fare – Eaton Rapids | Eaton Rapids, MI | (517) 663-4870
Family Fare – Marshall | Marshall, MI | (269) 781-8962
Family Fare – Vicksburg | Vicksburg, MI | (269) 649-1698

Family Fare – Northfield | Northfield, MN | (507) 645-9514
Family Fare – Litchfield | Litchfield, MN | (320) 693-7246

Family Fare – Holdrege | Holdrege, NE | (308) 995-6285
Family Fare – Grover | Omaha , NE | (402) 551-6865
Family Fare – W. Center | Omaha , NE | (402) 334-1415
Family Fare – 108th St. | Omaha , NE | (402) 493-5833
Family Fare – Bellevue | Bellevue, NE | (402) 291-7170
Family Fare – Council Bluffs | Council Bluffs, IA | (712) 322-4326
Family Fare – Blair | Blair, NE | (402) 426-4757
Family Fare – Papillion | Papillion, NE | (402) 408-2401
Family Fare – Elkhorn | Omaha , NE | (402) 896-4339

Family Fare – West Fargo | West Fargo, ND | (701) 277-5566
Family Fare – 25th St. | Fargo , ND | (701) 237-3007
Family Fare – West Dickinson | Dickinson , ND | (701) 483-8046
Family Fare – North | Bismarck , ND | (701) 258-7791
Family Fare – South | Bismarck , ND | (701) 255-3517
Family Fare – Sunrise | Bismarck , ND | (701) 751-7474
Family Fare – Turnpike | Bismarck , ND | (701) 224-0037
Family Fare – Mandan | Mandan, ND | (701) 667-5748

Family Fare – St. Patrick’s | Rapid City , SD | (605) 343-4326
Family Fare – Baken Park | Rapid City , SD | (605) 399-1377